Tactical

The "Not in the face!" School of Violence

In this article, we discuss how the bad advice of irrelevant instructors teaching technique without context will get you killed. Don't get killed. Read up.

December 30, 2019
By:
ISG Team

Intro

Here's the thing about violence: it's like fire. It's a great servant, but it's a cruel master.

When you're in control of it, it's pretty neat. Everyone thinks they know what's up until it gets out of hand. That's what we want to focus on; Not the dojo, not the sparring partner, but the situation that spins out of control. We want you to leave this article understanding two absolutely critical elements of information:

How to assess whether or not information is bad, and how to apply good judgment when working around violence.

If you're just starting out you might, like a great many people, watch videos on martial arts or fighting and think "That looks like it'd work". Give the technique some cool sounding name, and you're an instructor now. To the novice, these guys look like they're masters of violence. They fling their training partners around and dominate them physically while doing stuff that makes you think "hey, I could do that!"

Heres' the real deal: you probably can't.

The physical act of fighting is three major parts: Technical skill, Physical prowess, and Tenacity.

Often as not, it's pretty easy to determine who is credible and who isn't, but the world of fighting is complex. To add to the problem, when you're starting out looking up, it seems like everyone knows more than you. Case in point:

Hand-to-Hand Combat Skills So You Can Get to Your Gun Quicker

The headline of this article is a steaming dumpster fire, but getting to guns quicker? That means I should win, right? After all, guns are the ultimate equalizer, right?

We don't wanna get boring harping on the same stuff, but whoever posted this crap has never been in a fight. Ever. If they have, it was some chest thumping, scratch fight while piss drunk at the bar. It wasn't a serious threat to their life, and that's where we'll start. I will guarantee you they've never had to access their weapon with another person attacking them at "rage infection" levels of intensity.

How can you tell? Glad you asked.

Timing, Platform, Positioning

Even if you're not a martial artist, you can understand a few key elements of this problem:

  • Introducing a gun into a fight means the stakes just went through the roof.
  • Accessing a handgun while you're in the middle of a fight is a physical task that requires use of at least one arm. If you commit one arm to drawing a weapon, your adversary now has one less limb to negotiate attacking or fending.
  • In real fights, you're not always standing with your feet firmly planted on the ground with an adversary waiting for you to touch his gloves. Understand the Spheres of Violence!
  • There's not always one attacker.
As we mention in Spheres of Violence, *real* violent criminals don't give up and throw their hands out to the sides with you grab their cheeks.
This is what "throwing the fight" looks like.

Think on these things. The author of this article can't wrap his mind around the *fact* that no one is going to stop fighting because you pressed his jaw.

Neither does he have any experience fighting under these circumstances; this is evident in his thinking that the space this creates is sufficient. It isn't. ...And again, getting your ass beat isn't an excuse to draw your "trusty blaster".

In order to access your weapon safely, you need to ensure that your draw comes on the tail end of your having a dominant position and justification. This is beyond the scope of any internet article or youtube video. Don't delude yourself into thinking you can 'learn' this by watching. You need real experience on this matter. It's deadly serious, and it's *far* too common to neglect.

Escalation of Force

The military and police get lectured on this pretty continually, but how about the citizen?

Does a guy beating your ass mean you get to kill him? When you read articles like the one on Personal Defense World, what we want to impart on you is the following:

"Defanging the Snake"
  • Does this person have a firm grasp on reality? (A quick word on that: Assume you will *always* be fighting someone physically stronger, technically more competent, and instinctually more aggressive. Don't ever expect some "Defanging the snake" trick will work. Ever.)
  • Is the advice this person is giving me likely to get me into or out of trouble?
  • If I were to tell the responding officer what happened, would I need to call my significant other or bestie to post bail?

Establishing the Need for Lethal Force

If you have good hand to hand skills, as advocated (but not practiced) in the article, you might be paint yourself into an unjustifiable homicide by accessing your gun. Before you try to segue from defending yourself physically to 'stacking bodies' or whatever the ridiculous internet phrase de jour is, you need to be able to establish and verbally articulate three things:

  1. This person was intent on killing me and I know that because...
  2. The person was physically capable of killing me, and I know that because...
  3. The person had the opportunity to kill me when he/she did, and I know that because...

If you can't establish that this person had the intent, capability, and opportunity to kill you, you've committed homicide. Congratulations, and welcome to the legal system.

Finally, don't use this as an excuse to *find* those reasons after the fact, or try to convince people you were in fear for your life when you weren't. If they aren't legitimately there, don't get your trusty blaster and kill someone then bleat "I was in fear for my life" to the 9-1-1 dispatcher. Unless you love prison.

If you'd rather be judged by 12 than carried by 6, make sure you'd have been carried by 6 either way.

Timing Errors

The gun community is over-ripe with "Kill 'em all and let God sort them out" type thinking. Be above that. Idiomatic, sloganized thought like this is the hallmark of the inexperienced amateur. Think about a couple things instead:

Look at the physiology of this encounter: Who has more free strength to work with? The gunslinger here has a pistol in one hand and isn't even binding a limb on the 'bad guy' (who already looks like he's given up). Don't fall for this.

Craig Douglas of Shivworks has what he calls a "timing error". This occurs when a person accesses a weapon without being able to retain it. The results are almost always malfunctions, fights over the gun itself (in which the stronger, more tenacious, more technical fighter almost always ends up with it... think back to the above point), or the witnesses viewing the person who accessed the gun as the aggressor.

This concept is so critically important for the citizen who carries, that we can't overstate it enough. If you carry a gun, no matter who you are or what you do for a living, you should take ECQC.

Second, we can extend the logic of the timing error outside of the physical fight, and into the intellectual and legal space. Can you justify the use of force? If not, you're far better fighting it out than obsessing over how to get your gun in the fight.

Currency and relevance

Another consideration is that information needs to be current and relevant. Your skill and technique, like physical fitness, need maintenance. Things change, and your training should reflect this. As a part of your ongoing efforts, it's imperative that you maintain (or regain!) your physical fitness and continually test your ability under pressure. Conversely, there's a such thing as overtraining. In force on force, it's common to see guys who over-estimate the usefulness of their strength, speed, or technique. Being experienced is the best argument for being well rounded, but in general, cultivate some athleticism, pressure test your technique and tenacity, and realize the ultimate truth: The more you train, the more it will take a toll on your body. That means your time being a BAMF is limited; this is a strong argument for making good decision before violence breaks out.

The Obvious Solution

This will be brief: stop making excuses and train.

Remember that any training you do needs to be 100% pressure before it is "validated". If you have a partner who is willing to try out some techniques, they can't half-ass their approach. Don't grab the weakest guy in the dojo, or the guy know for being a rag doll. Find the baddest mongo in the joint, and pressure test it against him.  The people writing these articles aren't going to rely on your knowledge of violence, they're going to rely on your ignorance of it. It's shameful, dishonorable, disrespectful, and dangerous to do so, but that's the state of the industry.

No one but you is going to put you above the guys who would rather pull a pistol than get hit in the face. It's up to you to learn through experience, so don't take our word for it. Find an instructor who puts on classes with full contact Force on Force in which sim-guns, training knives, and combative are in play. It's even better if it's unscripted. If you want to learn how to fight, you need to be willing to get punched in the face.

Go put in the work, and see for yourself.

ISG Team

PS: Some offense intended.

join the pack

Get personalized training & consultation.

LEARN MORE

Latest articles

The Deep End

The Train

The old American Experiment is on some troubling tracks. Here are some thoughts on what we can do.

Mindset

Inauguration Day

A short blog post bringing some perspective to the wider world as we navigate Inauguration Day.

Mindset

2020: Basic Training for the Decade

Here's to hoping for a safe, happy, and productive 2021 - while acknowledging that it was very likely the first in a series of very troubled years.

Technical

Mythbusting: Baofengs Radios

You see these radios everywhere; influencers trying to look technically competent post pictures of their Baofengs constantly. Why is that bad? Let's dive in.

Technical

The Definitive IFAK Article

The one-stop-shop article for what you need and where to get it. No marketed or paid-for premade solutions here.

Firearm Skills

Guns of ISG: The Makarov

In this article, we will outline below why we believe that the Makarov should be considered as a well-rounded compact EDC carry gun for OCONUS use.Enter the Mak

Mythbusting

Bad practice: Is your spouse is a Liability?

The case of Mark and Patricia McCloskey have one dramatic lesson to be learned - if you're not discussing security with your family, you're wrong.

The Deep End

Spheres of Violence 3: The Universal Language

Those encouraging violence in our society are trapping us in a deadly game. We discuss the outcomes and consequences of the "Boys of Low Standing" and violence.

The Training Mindset

Here at ISG, we talk much on the topic of “mindset” as it applies to situations - here we discuss mindset as it relates to training.

K9 Emergencies 101: Bleeding Control

Your dogs get hurt, too. Learn to apply the skills and acquire the equipment needed for everything you'll want to keep your puppers safe from catastrophe.

Mindset

Trust your Gut: Reading People

A tremendous amount of what we communicate is done without saying a word. We look at some of the things to look for when interacting with people.

Technical

Radio Communication 201: Short Range HAM Radio Operation

In this article, Drew breaks down the basics of short-range HAM radio, bands, and operations to better understand their pros and cons in the US and abroad.

never miss an update.

Get all the newest articles sent to you first.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.